I am unique
Nov. 5th, 2023 12:40 amThe chances of anyone else having had the following specific experience are pretty much nil: When I read Tracy Deonn's Legendborn, I got tripped up by a false friend between Breton and Welsh.
Legendborn is a YA fantasy book in which a Black sixteen year old girl ends up involved in a secret society of descendants of the Arthurian knights who fight demons. They call the demons by Welsh names, so when "isel" and "uchel" had been explained already and "goruchel" was brought up I kinda skipped over the explanation going "it's uchel + gor as in korrigan with a mutation, cool, got it, moving on" and it... Was not that. So it was a bit of a record scratch when the goruchel's actuality showed up. NOT THAT THE AUTHOR COULD HAVE BEEN EXPECTED TO THINK THIS WOULD HAPPEN
More widely applicable review:
I enjoyed it. I like Bree and Sel a lot, both separately and together. Alice is MVP. LOVED the healer guy. I'll read the sequel.
I did think the pacing at the start was a bit slow and at the end a bit too fast -- expect for when Bree gets into a mental conversation with a ghost for however long it is and I was like "is time standing still for everyone else or are they having deadly swordfights while she's just chilling?"
There were too many characters. When one of them was revealed as a traitor, my only thought was "who the fuck is this?!"
I am not a fan of love triangles, but this one was ok because (a) it's Arthuriana, I was braced for it and (b) it's an actual triangle, ie one of the two dudes have an important relationship/care about each other.
I cannot speak about how the themes of Black (generational) trauma were handled, but the author is a US Black woman. Saw reviews saying it was welldone.
I liked how the grief was handled.
I did like.
One thing that really REALLY bugged me though was the complete and utter lack of any reference to any of the female characters in Arthuriana. This is especially egregious when you consider that the titular descendants of the Knights of the Round Table include descendants of ARTHUR AND LANCELOT. #JusticeForGuinevere2023
Overall: Enjoyed it. Cover is gorgeous. Curious about where it's going, will read the sequel.
Legendborn is a YA fantasy book in which a Black sixteen year old girl ends up involved in a secret society of descendants of the Arthurian knights who fight demons. They call the demons by Welsh names, so when "isel" and "uchel" had been explained already and "goruchel" was brought up I kinda skipped over the explanation going "it's uchel + gor as in korrigan with a mutation, cool, got it, moving on" and it... Was not that. So it was a bit of a record scratch when the goruchel's actuality showed up. NOT THAT THE AUTHOR COULD HAVE BEEN EXPECTED TO THINK THIS WOULD HAPPEN
More widely applicable review:
I enjoyed it. I like Bree and Sel a lot, both separately and together. Alice is MVP. LOVED the healer guy. I'll read the sequel.
I did think the pacing at the start was a bit slow and at the end a bit too fast -- expect for when Bree gets into a mental conversation with a ghost for however long it is and I was like "is time standing still for everyone else or are they having deadly swordfights while she's just chilling?"
There were too many characters. When one of them was revealed as a traitor, my only thought was "who the fuck is this?!"
I am not a fan of love triangles, but this one was ok because (a) it's Arthuriana, I was braced for it and (b) it's an actual triangle, ie one of the two dudes have an important relationship/care about each other.
I cannot speak about how the themes of Black (generational) trauma were handled, but the author is a US Black woman. Saw reviews saying it was welldone.
I liked how the grief was handled.
I did like
bit of Merlin lore
that it used the "son of a demon" Merlin origin storyOne thing that really REALLY bugged me though was the complete and utter lack of any reference to any of the female characters in Arthuriana. This is especially egregious when you consider that the titular descendants of the Knights of the Round Table include descendants of ARTHUR AND LANCELOT. #JusticeForGuinevere2023
Overall: Enjoyed it. Cover is gorgeous. Curious about where it's going, will read the sequel.